Freight Agent 1099 Employment: What Are the Benefits of 1099 vs W2?

Freight Agent 1099 Employment: What Are the Benefits of 1099 vs W2?

Both W-2 and 1099s are tax forms reserved for certain types of workers. Employees in the freight industry can fall under either category, depending upon the way the business is structured: a traditional freight broker or a freight agency.

The working conditions and benefits of 1099 vs. W2 employment are also separated by many more things than just the tax implications. Make an informed decision about working at a brokerage or as an independent freight agent with the information broken down in the sections below.

What is W2 Employment in the Freight Industry?

A W-2 freight broker is a conventional employee that’s on the brokerage’s payroll with a fixed rate of pay (salary or hourly), a specific set of employer-determined benefits, and who is managed and directed fully by the brokerage and their policies.

The IRS Form W-2 is reserved for employees that are classified as part-time or full-time employees during a given tax year. It’s essentially the employee’s Wage and Tax Statement — a full record of their compensation, benefits, and taxes paid to Social Security, Medicare, etc.

W-2 workers would include:

  • Hourly part-time employees or sales reps at a freight brokerage

  • All salaried full-time employees at the brokerage

  • The executives and managers of the brokerage

What is 1099 Employment in the Freight Industry?

By contrast, a 1099 freight agent is their own boss — although they may be working under the name (and with the added brand equity) of a larger freight brokerage. An independent freight agency makes its own hours and finds its own business opportunities without the close oversight, control, and direct management of a brokerage.

The 1099-NEC tax form is reserved for workers who are considered independent contractors, not employees. Freight agents use the 1099 because they are workers who have been paid at least $600 for services in a given year, but didn’t have taxes withheld from their income under an employment arrangement. Unlike the W-2, 1099 agents are responsible for filing their own taxes as an independent business. The 1099 form shows only the worker’s gross income without any taxes withheld.

Examples of 1099 workers in the freight and logistics industry would include:

  • Freight agents who are supported by a freight broker, but serve their own clients directly

  • Consultants or freelancers offering one-time services (gig work)

  • Contractors hired through outside vendors

Benefits of 1099 Employment vs. W2

1099 — Independent Freight Agent

W2 — Freight Broker Employee

  • Personalized support from broker, but not under their direct control

  • Control over your own benefits arrangements

  • Flexible work schedule (when, where, and however long you want)

  • Choose your own clients and build your own book of business

  • Pay is primarily based on commission

  • No limits on potential income — commission-centric pay structure compensates you for however much work you do for how many clients

  • No taxes withheld from paycheck; the worker is responsible for all the taxes

  • Use whatever tools you prefer to get the job done

  • Beholden to the broker’s direct control and the company has the right to assign additional projects

  • May be eligible for benefits offered by the company

  • Employer sets hours of work, may require in-office work, and decides the duration of the job

  • Employer can discharge the worker and end any relationship with the broker’s clients

  • Income is primarily hourly or salary

  • Predictable, set pay structure supplemented by a minority percentage of commission

  • Brokerage withholds state and federal taxes(Social Security, Medicare, etc.)

  • Must use employer’s preferred tools and processes

Why Become a 1099 Freight Agent?

The choice to work as a traditional on-premise employee at a brokerage or as an independent freight agent is a personal one. For many, it comes down to level of ambition, the importance of flexibility, and self-confidence. For others, the tax advantages of 1099 employment can be a major attraction.

1099 Tax Benefits

Freight agents operating under a 1099 designation are required to pay self-employment tax, which includes Medicare and Social Security taxes — and which is equivalent to the FICO tax percentages withheld by W-2 employers. However, one of the biggest benefits of being a 1099 employee is that the premiums workers pay for health insurance can actually be deducted from their self-employment income. This effectively reduces the taxable income of 1099 employees and, therefore, their total self-employment tax liability.

Earning Benefits of 1099

The freight industry workers who find 1099 work appealing are betting on themselves to sell. If you’re a talented sales professional, this can make 1099 employment far more lucrative and rewarding. What you’re trading away — a conventional salary/benefits security blanket and a predictable schedule — you’re gaining back in total freedom to set your own hours and choose your own business opportunities with no ceiling on what you can earn. The sky is truly the limit when you’re keeping as much as 70% commission all to yourself. Freight agents who put in the work are rewarded in ways a W-2 employee could never achieve.

If you value flexibility and autonomy, and do not mind the responsibilities of organizing your own taxes and benefits, this can be a prime opportunity to advance your career and maximize your earnings. Get in touch with Freight Flex for more information.

Recent Posts

7 Perks of Working For Yourself as an Independent Freight Agent

May 05, 2024

Have you ever been frustrated with the rigid schedule,...

Read More

Freight Agent 1099 Employment: What Are the Benefits of 1099 vs W2?

May 05, 2024

Both W-2 and 1099s are tax forms reserved for certain types...

Read More

Get in Touch with Freight Flex

Contact us, and let's make some magic happen together!